Mercer Criminal Appeals Attorney

Understanding Your Right to Appeal in Mercer

Sometimes, the justice system doesn’t get it right. If you’ve been convicted or sentenced unfairly, an appeal might be your next step toward justice. An appeal is a formal request to a higher court to review and challenge the decision made in your original trial. The law sets strict deadlines for this process, so it’s critical to act quickly. We encourage you to contact the Logue Law Group at 412.389.0805 immediately to start your appeal.

The legal team at Logue Law Group is dedicated to walking you through the complex appeals process, keeping you informed every step of the way. Our Mercer criminal lawyers are prepared to vigorously defend your rights and work toward the best possible result for your case.

Client Testimonials

“The final outcome was overwhelmingly in my favor. I would strongly recommend their representation for anyone in need.”

“The entire process was seamless, resulting in a fantastic result. My gratitude goes to Sean.”

“Sean Logue epitomizes professionalism, and I would highly recommend him without a second thought.”

Logue Law Group is proud to handle all cases in Mercer. Our attorneys have had the honor of representing many clients during their most difficult times, offering a chance for a better future through criminal appeals.

A Closer Look at the Mercer Criminal Appeals Process

In most situations, you have the right to challenge a criminal court’s decision. An appeal involves asking a different court and a new judge to review your case for legal mistakes that might have resulted in an unfair trial. The appellate judge’s job is to spot errors in how the law was applied. This could include issues like the use of evidence that was obtained improperly or the incorrect interpretation of laws. A skilled Mercer criminal lawyer can help identify these errors.

How Appellate Judges Examine Your Trial

Filing an appeal doesn’t mean you get a completely new trial. Instead, a panel of judges will carefully review the official record of your original trial. This record includes:

• Transcripts of everything said by the Mercer DUI lawyers, witnesses, and judge, as documented by the court reporter.
• All evidence, including physical objects and testimonies, that were part of the court reporter’s transcript.
• Any documents related to the verdict from the jury or judge, including the instructions the judge gave to the jury.

The appeals process is known to be lengthy, often taking several months unless a quick decision is necessary.

Deadlines and Procedures for Criminal Appeals in Mercer

Under Pennsylvania law, as specified in the Pennsylvania Revised Code, you have 30 days from your sentencing or conviction to file an appeal. If you miss this deadline, your appeal will likely be dismissed, and the appeals court will not be able to review your case. Although the Pennsylvania Court of Appeals has other rules, this 30-day deadline is the most important one. Working with a Mercer DUI lawyer can ensure you meet all critical deadlines.

Necessity of Legal Representation for an Appeal

While the law does not require you to have a Mercer criminal lawyer for your appeal, it is highly recommended. Appeals are focused on legal principles and how they were applied, which can be very confusing for someone without legal training. Choosing to be represented by the Logue Law Group can greatly improve your chances of receiving a favorable outcome.

The Appeals Process for Criminal Defendants

Even though the legal arguments in an appeal can be complicated, the process itself is fairly straightforward. Here’s what you can expect:

1. Filing a Brief: You or your Mercer DUI lawyer will submit a detailed written argument, known as a brief, explaining why your trial was unfair and what solution you are seeking. The prosecutor will then submit their own brief to argue that the original decision should be upheld.
2. Oral Arguments: Both sides will present their cases verbally before the appeals judge. The judge might ask questions to get more clarification on certain legal points.
3. Decision: After reviewing the trial records, briefs, and oral arguments, the appellate judge will issue a ruling on your appeal in the following months.

How Appellate Judges Could Rule

In the legal world, understanding how the appellate process works is vital for anyone considering an appeal. Let’s break down how appellate judges might rule on your case, keeping in mind the application of the Pennsylvania Revised Code.

Paths to a Decision

When an appellate judge reviews your case, there are three primary outcomes:

• Affirmation of the Lower Court’s Ruling: The judge finds no error and agrees with the original court’s decision, so it remains unchanged.
• Remand for Further Proceedings: The judge finds an error and sends the case back to the lower court with instructions to reconsider certain aspects or conduct a new trial.
• Reversal of the Lower Court’s Decision: The judge disagrees with the lower court’s finding, effectively overturning the original decision.

If a case is reviewed by more than one judge, a simple majority is needed for a final decision. For example, on a panel of five judges, three must agree to finalize the ruling. A Mercer criminal lawyer can explain these potential outcomes in more detail. If a party is unhappy with the appellate decision, they may be able to seek another review from an even higher court.

Criminal Cases Eligible For Appeal

Nearly all criminal cases, with the exception of minor traffic infractions, can be appealed. This includes efforts to overturn a conviction, change a sentence, or stop an execution. Some of the most commonly appealed criminal cases involve:

• Gun offenses
• Sexual offenses
• Assault charges
• Drug-related crimes
• Domestic violence incidents
• Vehicular offenses
• White-collar crimes
• Federal offenses

If you aren’t sure whether your case can be appealed, our office provides complimentary consultations to discuss your situation. A Mercer DUI lawyer can assess the specifics of your case.

Common Grounds for Appeal

Simply being unhappy with the outcome of your case isn’t enough for a successful appeal. The Pennsylvania Revised Code requires that appeals be based on specific legal errors, such as:

• The use of improper evidence against you.
• Incorrect application of the law by the judge.
• Violations of your constitutional rights.
• The defense being denied access to critical evidence.
• Ineffective legal representation from your previous attorney.
• Jury tampering or misconduct.
• Unreasonable delays in prosecution.

Challenging a Bench Trial Verdict

If you chose a bench trial, your case was decided by a judge instead of a jury. If you believe the judge made a mistake, you can appeal to the Pennsylvania court of appeals. The appellate judges will review the trial record to see if the trial judge’s decision was legally sound. A Mercer criminal lawyer is essential for this process.

Key Appeal Strategies

There are two main strategies for appealing a decision from a bench trial:

• Abuse of Discretion: This argument claims that the trial judge’s decisions were unreasonable or not supported by the evidence presented.
• Reversible Error: This involves identifying significant legal mistakes that were so serious they undermine the fairness and validity of the trial’s outcome.

Contesting a Jury Trial Verdict

If a jury heard your case, you can appeal their decision if it seems to be unsupported by the facts or was influenced by legal errors. Examples of issues that can lead to an appeal include:

• Confusing or incorrect jury instructions from the judge.
• Misconduct by the jury during deliberation.
• Improper admission of prejudicial evidence.

Jury Tampering

Jury decisions must be made without any outside influence. An appeal is possible if there is evidence that any juror was improperly influenced, bribed, or threatened. A Mercer DUI lawyer can help investigate such claims.

Appealing a Sentence

You can appeal more than just a conviction; you can also appeal the sentence itself. The grounds for appealing a sentence include arguing that it was unlawful, unconstitutional, or excessive.

For instance, if someone was sentenced to more than one year for a misdemeanor burglary, that sentence would be both excessive and unlawful, as it exceeds the statutory maximum.

Navigating Pennsylvania’s Appellate Court System

In Pennsylvania, appeals are handled by appellate courts, which are separate from trial courts. The state is organized into 12 appellate districts, each with a different number of judges depending on its population and caseload. These courts review decisions from lower courts and also handle specific legal actions like habeas corpus petitions. For example, the First District Court of Appeals is responsible for hearing cases from Mercer County.

Strategies for Navigating Criminal Appeals

To succeed in a criminal appeal, you must show that a specific error occurred during your original trial. A conviction or sentence won’t be changed just because the outcome was not what you hoped for. Here are some crucial strategies for pursuing a criminal appeal with help from a Mercer criminal lawyer.

Essential Steps in Criminal Appeals

• Adhere to All Submission Deadlines: Timely filing is absolutely critical to the success of your appeal.
• Obtain Trial Transcripts and Records: These documents form the foundation of your appeal and must be carefully reviewed.
• Craft a Clear and Concise Brief: Your written argument should be persuasive and easy for the judges to understand.
• Engage a Skilled Mercer Criminal Appeals Lawyer: Professional legal guidance from an experienced Mercer DUI lawyer is invaluable.

Resources for Criminal Appeals

Pennsylvania Attorney General Crime Victim Services

Victims of crimes can find information and support here, particularly regarding how an appeal might affect them.

Pennsylvania State Bar Association

The association provides a downloadable fact sheet about the state’s court system, including the appellate courts, which answers many frequently asked questions.

FAQs About Navigating Mercer Criminal Appeals

Q: How do I start a criminal appeal?

A: The Pennsylvania Revised Code gives you 30 days from the trial court’s decision to file a notice of appeal. This process requires you or your Mercer criminal lawyer to submit a brief that details the trial court’s errors and the remedy you are seeking. Following this, both your attorney and the prosecutor will present their arguments to a panel of judges, who will then make a decision based on the briefs and arguments.

Q: Can the appellate court overturn my conviction or sentence?

A: Yes. An appellate court has the power to reverse a conviction, order a new trial, or confirm the original trial court’s decision.

Q: How long does the appeal process take?

A: Criminal appeals generally take at least three months, but the timeframe can be much longer depending on the appellate court’s schedule and the complexity of the case.

Q: Can I appeal my sentence?

A: Yes, you have the right to appeal your sentence if you believe it is illegal or unreasonably harsh. A Mercer DUI lawyer can advise you on this.

This guide is intended to make the criminal appeals process more understandable for those who need to navigate this challenging legal path.Navigating the appeals process can be overwhelming, but with the right legal team, you have a better chance at achieving justice. If you believe a legal error was made during your trial, do not hesitate. Contact Logue Law Group to discuss your case or call us at 412.389.0805 to explore your options for an appeal.